Google

no privacy right in identity linked to ip address

The Ontario Court of Appeal released its decision in R v. Ward earlier today. The case involved the conviction of a worthless low-life pedophile by the name of David Ward.

The police were able to find him due, in part, by tracking down his IP address and asking his ISP to provide the identity of the customer using the IP address at the time. His ISP did so voluntarily, even though the police did not have a search warrant. The appeal focused on whether or not he had been subject to unreasonable search and seizure, in violation of the the Charter of Rights, and whether or not he had a reasonable expectation of privacy.

The Court of Appeal’s decision concluded that the disclosure of this information by the ISP to the police did not violate his Charter ┬árights nor was there, nor should there have been, a reasonable expectation of privacy.

While my personal sentiments in respect of Mr. Ward would be that I could care less if he rotted in a jail cell for the rest of his days, the ends, as they say, do not always justify the means. And if the law is to be applied equally to everyone, I do believe there are some rather disconcerting implications regarding the conclusions in this case, notwithstanding the court’s attempt to put a ring fence around its application.

No time for the detailed analysis right now but it will be forthcoming. In the meantime, I encourage you to read the case – what do you think?

About

Technology lawyer in Toronto.

Posted in Uncategorized Tagged with: , , , , , , , , ,

Recent Tweets

  • sec finalizes and adopts regulation a+ (rules governing crowdfunding). d-ma.ca/19pQPkL 3 days ago
  • apparently amazon’s unlimited storage is not available in canada. oh well. 3 days ago
  • we have now officially reached the pinnacle of 3d printing: behold, the pancake-bot. d-ma.ca/191P9y0 3 days ago
  • tennessee sues fcc to block expansion of municipal broadband. d-ma.ca/1FMIlCx 3 days ago
  • amazon’s unlimited storage would be great, if it worked: “We’re sorry! There was an internal error in our system.” 4 days ago
  • exoskeleton that serves as a wearable chair of sorts. quite clever. d-ma.ca/1HMBDNP 4 days ago
  • amazon offers unlimited cloud storage for us$60/yr. <scratches head, tries to figure out what the catch is> d-ma.ca/1xiCRMV 4 days ago
  • the consequences of unplanned death on your digital legacy aren’t pretty, especially if you use good security. d-ma.ca/1BpFdFi 5 days ago
  • what i find fascinating about this is the huge impact on car design that self-driving can (and should) have. d-ma.ca/1EEXtfQ 5 days ago
  • facebook open sources tool to optimize app and website performance. d-ma.ca/1FCtmLo 5 days ago

Follow Me on Twitter

archives